You are reading an archived post from The Crowe's Perch Message Board.
AMERICAN RED CROSS: 1 800 HELP NOW
The Crowe' s Perch Archives
    > Russell's Revellers: get your fan fuel here:)
        > An Afghani-American perspective
  

Page 1 2 3 4 5

Author Comment
Onnie
Frequently Perched
(9/17/01 10:02:30 am)
Re: An Afghani-American perspective
Quote:
Just as an example of our own unawareness: nobody seems to remember our stance in Chechnya, where we basically sat on our hands while Muslim civilians were being slaughtered. I'm not trying to take a side in that particular issue, but it's those kinds of foreign circumstances that have painted a pretty bad picture of us to our enemies - and we should be aware of that.


Unfortunately, it is rather hard to pick and choose who to help and where to step in and when. I wouldn't want the job.

When we do step in we are "policing the world" and condemed for it. When we don't step in "We should have done something how dare we sit on the sidelines." Sometimes it is the entire UN's decision but the US takes the major lick for the action or non-action.

Really the world needs to come together under the UN so it is truly a world effort focusing on regions that need help. Of course we all know that's not going to happen very soon but hey it is nice to dream right?

AZLady
Frequently Perched
(9/17/01 10:26:49 am)
Lady Diedre
I've been think back on your statement that the rest of the world laughs at us for thinking we are "the best." In normal times, I truly don't. Please keep in mind, however, that NOTHING like this has happened on American soil in nearly two hundred years. Obviously it has in most of the rest of the world, I am very familiar with the history of WWII. But I don't believe anything like has happened in the lifetimes of most of us anywhere in the world, in peacetime, that killed so many thousands of civilians.

Personally, if I don't keep thinking NOW that we are the best, we are the strongest, we will get through this, I don't believe I could bear it.

Tricia
Perch Pro
(9/17/01 10:59:12 am)
Innocent Civilians
Approximately 200,000 people, the vast majority innocent civilians, died after the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima.

About 50,000 were killed with another atomic bomb in Nagasaki a few days later.

On the night of February 14, 1945 it is estimated that 25,000 to 30,000 German civilians were killed in one Allied bombing raid, using something called "incendiaries", which created a firestorm.

In Britain, during the bombing raids that took place from September 1940 to May 1941, known as "The Blitz", 18,000 tons of high explosives were dropped on England. About 35,000 civilians were killed.

Kira Scurro
Perch Pro
(9/17/01 11:09:39 am)
Re: Innocent Civilians
i'm feeling a lot better about the direction of this thread now. az seems to feel i'm against america (my interpretation...so that could be the wrong word...but i see where you're coming from, az) i'm no less patriotic than anyone else out there. i just react strongly to feelings of america being the greatest country on earth. we're pretty damned good, but we can be pretty damned bad, too. if we forget that we're allowing the rhetoric to mow us down.
Quote:
Both the extreme right and extreme left need to move to the center with the rest of us.
i'm sorry, i can't do this just because of what's happened. not if it means i must follow an agenda that i implicitly disapprove of. solidarity means nothing if you believe you're following the wrong path.

i'm also starting to feel a little better about the administration's plans. as long as i'm listening to powell and not bush, i can rest a little easier. this is still a free country so i can call the president whatever i like. i can't profess to being the most tactful when i'm strongly aroused.

why was it necessary to cry out "war!"? there have been terrorist attacks all over the world before this without the victimized country declaring war. no one actually knows that "going to war" doesn't necessarily mean what we have known war to be. the same purpose would have been served if we had just been told that we were mobilizing troops to find the terrorists cells...all over the world. the same sanctions would have been granted by our government. it could have all been handled a lot less sensationally. wasn't the actual event terrifying enough without the additional bulldog approach? this is why i dislike our president's presentation of this crisis.

but others would disagree, because we have always been a country who had to look the best, retaliate the fastest, and be offended the quickest. with the surveys mounting of how many americans are ready to go to war, our global position evidently exactly reflects our citizens' feelings. my personal opinion is this is as wrong a way for individuals to react to those around them as it is for our country to react to the rest of the world. i hate to see this attitude in our leaders.

onnie, i think we're on the same track, so i won't respond in depth to all of your points. i appreciate your response to mine, though. i think most of the points i made have already been examined and explained perfectly by others. thanks, guys.

~BELIEVE~

AZLady
Frequently Perched
(9/17/01 11:38:04 am)
Tricia and Kira
Tricia, note that I said, "in peacetime." I am more than aware of how many thousands of civilians died in Europe and Japan. Correct me if I'm wrong, and I'm sure someone will!, but until Tuesday the US didn't think it was at war with anyone. I'm not sure what to call what we are in now, but it hasn't been peacetime since Tuesday.

Kira, I know I've been way too emotional about this. I do realize that there are many ways of looking at all the whys, wherefores, etc. of this disaster. But for the immediate future I stand by my statement that we must stand united and not let arguments over what we should or should have not done in WWII, Korea, Vietnam, Bosnia, Somalia.....Lord, there are way too many of these....cause us to become, and appear to the rest of the world to become, divided in this cause.

I truly hope when this is over....assuming, of course, that any of us are still around when this is over...we can go back to being liberals, conservatives, or whatever and still have the right to every different opinon our very diverse population can come up with....without, of course, attempting to impose those opinions by force.

Peace to both of you.

AZLady
Frequently Perched
(9/17/01 12:24:26 pm)
I keep thinking of things I wish I'd said
Kira, I'm praying, as I'm sure you are, that our nation's leaders take us in a direction most of us will be willing to follow, with a few reservations, perhaps, but follow none the less. I'm also praying that somewhere down the line what seems to be the right direction now, doesn't land us in even worse trouble later. Too bad we can't live life in reverse, isn't it?

Bush's rhetoric, I agree, is somewhat over the top, probably because he feels this is what the nation needs to hear. But his statements, as well as those of others I have read, that we will only act once we are sure we are right, have been very encouraging to me. The fact that he is working with leaders from around the world toward this common goal, rather than riding off with both guns (or missiles) blazing, is also encouraging as is the Attorney General's strong condemnation of hate attacks against Arabs living in this country....not that those a**holes responsible for the attacks are going to listen to him or anyone else.

I don't think you are unAmerican....just perhaps slightly misguided, in my humble opinion (joking here!) I also am feeling better about the direction this thread is taking.

Again, peace

Onnie
Frequently Perched
(9/17/01 12:26:14 pm)
Re: An Afghani-American perspective
I understand everyone is emtional. Rightly so and I hope my replies have tried to sound clear headed. (Even if I am not honestly feeling clear headed when doing something else that doesn't involve a reply.)

I have been reading back over the thread and noticed (or perhaps it was another one) the mention that perhaps we should send a ton of food into the country to gain support. I have a couple of questions;

1) Support for .... That the people over throw the goverment or force them to hand over bin Laden?

These people are unarmed. Wait this says it better about their lives:

Quote:
Why are thousands of people fleeing Afghanistan in search of havens like Australia? What could have driven the escape of the Afghanis rescued by the Tampa?

Four Corners takes viewers on a shocking journey into Afghanistan to reveal the horror of life under Taliban rule.

In this powerful film from Britain's Channel 4, reporter Saira Shah goes in search of her father's birthplace to find a nation devastated by war, drought and one of the most repressive regimes on the planet.

Shah leaves behind a sea of Afghani refugees on the Pakistan side of the border to begin a cat and mouse game with agents from the Taliban's Ministry for the Prevention of Vice and the Promotion of Virtue.

She links up with an underground group, the Revolutionary Association of the Women of Afghanistan (RAWA). RAWA provide chilling, secret footage of public executions of men and women at the main soccer stadium in Kabul.

Shah asks the Taliban Foreign Minister if it's right that executions are carried out in a place of entertainment funded by international aid. The minister replies that the international community should build a separate facility for executions.

RAWA takes Shah to a clandestine school for girls. It's run by women teachers who have been banned from working by the Taliban. "If they find out that we're running a course here, they could hang us all," says one.

Shah visits a secret beauty salon where women seek a measure of normality in a world gone mad. "This is a form of resistance," says one woman as she paints her nails. "We're defying the Taliban."

Shah tours a gynaecological hospital where the desperate plight of women can be clearly seen. The place is filthy, with few doctors or medicines. More women die in childbirth in Afghanistan than anywhere else, Shah reports.

She then heads to the front line of the civil war in north-east Afghanistan. There she finds graphic evidence that the Taliban have been torturing and massacring unarmed civilians.

This is a harrowing and depressing portrait of a country ruled by terror. But Shah discovers slivers of hope among the poor and the weak, as they battle on in a daily struggle against tyranny.


So the coalition gets support but, one way or another, then these people have to be armed to do anything against their goverment. That means those women painting their nails in definace carrying guns. That means their kidos facing scud missiles. That still means civilians dying. That still also means our hands are dirty because someone has to give them something to stand up to these people. Finger nail polish isn't going to drop 50,000 troops (if I have the last count correct.)

2) Giving the people food or other services.

These people aren't currently living the way they are because it hasn't been tried. If, again, I have my figures correct the United States spends over $75 million a year in relief efforts. However, nothing has changed.

While fighting Russia, bin Laden expended a vast amount of funds on hospitals and schools. Now, he doesn't or more importantly the Tilban doesn't. There is a reason for that. They needed the country's backing or the populace because the US wasn't going to all out go to War with Russia (Cold war nuke issue.) While I agree relief work has a profound effect you have to be able to get there and, more importantly, get it to the right place for it to work. Before now that was something that wasn't really possible without inflaming an bad situation to worse. (On a global scale.)

3) This is still usurping a governments power.

No matter which way you slice it hands are going to get dirty. Be it a united UN force going in there or trying to get the populace to rise up. Between the two, just like the jet hurtling towards the school of 1000 children, I'd rather soliders got their hands dirty then a 8 year old carrying a gun next to his mother.

Quote:
why was it necessary to cry out "war!"? there have been terrorist attacks all over the world before this without the victimized country declaring war.


Because many times, sadly, "we" (being more than just the US) need a big one-sided excuse to actually go to where a huge problem exists. The world in a gobal recession and resources are not finte and "we" can only spread out so much or do so much when causes are devided (particularlly within the UN.) For example: Turkey could really go after many in the UN when they screamed for terrorists to be turned over to them and several overseas went on off on "humanity" and still harbor them. It isn't right just like...

There is so much hunger in the world that we shouldn't ever HAVE to encourage farmers not to farm. However the reality is someone has to gross product pay for them to farm and to get the food over there and for it to get to the right place. When so many countries don't have money to begin with, we could easily, with everything else, go completely bankrupt and then be able to help no one.

Luckly, Bush has one of the most competent, well picked staff in the history of any President I have known in office while alive. Whatever Bush is, like or dislike him, he's got the heavy guns of intelligent, experinced, and level headed people on the job.

Kira Scurro
Perch Pro
(9/17/01 12:45:54 pm)
Re: An Afghani-American perspective
and for that i am thankful, onnie. az, may i make a giant leap, and say maybe part of the reason you are having a hard time with all of this is because of your son being in the military. i would think having someone so closely involved would make one want to believe that his possible danger is for all the right reasons. i could be wrong, but it's just a thought.

i wanted to mention something that i haven't seen noted anywhere. i didn't know the details myself until i read the newspaper story yesterday. there are 2 young american women, 24 and 29, at this moment in an afghanistan jail. they are there for getting caught redhanded showing a video of jesus in a muslim home. these women were missionaries there to help the poverty stricken people in many ways. up until tuesday almost everyone involved thought they would probably get a brief jail sentence and be exported. now that all western sympathizers, including these women's families, have fled the country, no one believes these girls will ever get out alive. this is just one story of the many affected by this crisis.

~BELIEVE~

AZLady
Frequently Perched
(9/17/01 5:15:47 pm)
RE: An Afghani-American Perspective
Awful about those young aide workers, Kira. I had heard about it briefly before but did not know the details. How much courage they must have had in their faith, to go a country where even referring to any God but Allah, much less believing in one or trying to share your belief with others, means death.

I will add them to my prayers.

Torri
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 5:44:21 am)
Re: An Afghani-American perspective
I heard the author of the original e-mail interviewed last night on KABC 790. When he's not writing thought provoking e-mails, he's the author of non-fiction children's books. His father is Afghani, his mother is American. He was born and raised in Afghanistan but has lived in the US for the past 36 years. He currently lives in the San Francisco area.

He said that he originally sent this to about 20 friends. The radio host who was interviewing him (Mr. KABC) said that he'd had no less than 75 copies of the e-mail forwarded to him. One caller even stated that the e-mail was reproduced in an Israeli newspaper.

The host & guest also discussed bin Laden. Bin Laden has quite a few brothers and sisters living in the US...mostly in the Boston area. The US based family members have donated millions of dollars to Harvard University and deeply dislike their brother Osama. I'd heard this information last week as well...I sometimes wonder if this profound hatred of the US wasn't somehow born of something more "personal" in bin Laden's background...that is, maybe we're "the great Satan" for far more personal reasons than any of us may have suspected. Just a thought.

Torri
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 5:55:35 am)
Re: Feeding the people
Quote:
I am not an expert on conventional warfare but the Russian tried using more air-to-ground fighting. Missiles don't go very far down caves unless you're a real good shot. Ground-to-ground fighting is the only way to get in to all the underground hiding places. Nothing against the Russian people but I think our armed forces are much better equipped, and they are going to have the people behide them, plus we will have allies fighting with us.

My father and I were discussing this last night. He's retired but spent his entire career working in the defense industry. He told me that the main reason the Afghans were so successful in fighting off the Soviets is because of the Stinger missiles the US provided. The guidence system on a Stinger is virually impossible to out-maneuver because the missile is accurate and fast. He also said that not all of the Stingers we provided have been accounted for. :/

AZLady
Frequently Perched
(9/18/01 6:32:10 am)
An Afghani-American Perspective
Wow, so now we're the victim of really bad sibling rivalry? Seriously, most Arab-Americans probably still have family and close friends in their homeland. I would hope they are on the phone or the e-mail with anyone they still have in Arab countries urging them to help us. I'm undoubtedly being overly optimistic here, but hope is all I have left.

babzee 
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 8:23:55 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Quote:
September 13, 2001 Talk about it E-mail story Print


COMMENTARY
Islam Must Challenge Its Dark Doctrines

By YOSSI KLEIN HALEVI,


In the emerging debate over how extensively to define the enemy facing the West we need to avoid both wishful thinking and hysteria.

The minimalists who insist that the enemy is only a small band of fanatics around Osama bin Laden severely underestimate the penetration of extremist doctrine within much of mainstream Islam, especially in the Arab world. But those who invoke a war of civilizations—a conflict between Western democracy and international Islam—risk widening the circle of enmity to large parts of the Islamic world that have so far been immune to the appeal of jihad, or holy war.

Far from being regarded as fringe lunatics, the terrorists who struck against U.S. civilian and military targets are widely regarded as heroes within the Arab world. Religious edicts have been issued in Arab countries endorsing the attack, and thousands danced in the streets of the West Bank and Gaza. That pathological response isn't just the result of anger at perceived injustice, but of years of hate indoctrination in mosques and from state-controlled media. Indeed, only in the Arab world is Holocaust denial a mainstream notion.

Islamic doctrine easily lends itself to extremist cooptation. Islam divides the world into two regions: Dar al Harb, or the house of war, containing all territories ruled by non-Muslims, and Dar al Islam, or the house of Islam, which is destined to dominate the former. In a world groping toward planetary interconnectedness, this Islamic doctrine—which justifies the madness of holy war—must be challenged by Muslims themselves.

Humanistic Muslims need to face the lethal consequences of their theology toward non-Muslims. Apologetics about the nobility of Islam aren't good enough anymore. Just as much of Christianity has confronted its anti-Jewish theology, and many Jews are struggling to uproot the exclusivist strain within Judaism, tolerant Muslims can no longer afford to defend Islam's more problematic concepts.

We are all heirs to complex religious traditions; the obligation of believers is to preserve the beauty of their faith while transforming its negative residues.

Those who try to shift the blame for the latest terrorist atrocities on U.S. support for Israel miss several key points. The Arab war against Israel isn't over occupation but the right of a Jewish state to exist. Last year, at Camp David, former Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered to withdraw from almost all the territories and to share Jerusalem with the Palestinians—and the Temple Mount with Islam.

More broadly, the terrorist's holy war isn't aimed ultimately at Israel but the West. Muslim nations are among the the most vociferous in ideologically opposing globalization—not just its excesses but also its blessings, like a free media and a sense of shared responsibility for international stability.

Indeed, perhaps Israel's greatest offense to Arab sensibilities is its very Westerness, proof for many Muslims of its supposed colonialist essence. Western standards of human rights—which Arab propagandists routinely use to excoriate Israel—are almost unknown within the Muslim world.

Still, it would be disastrous to declare Islam itself the enemy. For many Muslims, the doctrines of holy war and of Dar al Islam are irrelevant to their faith, and have in effect been allowed to lapse. Sufis, or Muslim mystics, go further, transforming holy war into a spiritual doctrine, a battle against one's own imperfections.

Demonizing one of the world's great faiths is an affront against all religions.

The terrorists want nothing more than to widen this war to include the whole Islamic world. And those in the Arab world—especially Yasser Arafat—who actively nurture the culture of terrorism yet pretend to condemn it hope to avoid the West's judgment. Neither should be allowed to dictate the U.S. response to terrorism.
___


Yossi Klein Halevi's latest book is "At the Entrance to the Garden of Eden: A Jew's Search for God with Christians and Muslims in the Holy Land" (William Morrow, 2001).

For information about reprinting this article, go to www.lats.com/rights/register.htm

Strength and Honor

The enemy is fanaticism, extremism, intolerance, hate.

Lady Deirdre
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 8:34:20 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Please keep in mind while reading this: it was written by a Jew, not a muslim. Which means, someone who knows islam from the outside, second-hand.
Not to say that he is wrong in anything (who am I to say that ;) ) but just be critical of what you read. For some of us that's a natural stance, for others not so. Anything anyone says about religion is inevitably interpretation, and we must always be aware of the context the speaker brings with him/her.

I like this one btw:
Quote:
We are all heirs to complex religious traditions; the obligation of believers is to preserve the beauty of their faith while transforming its negative residues.

Communiaction: shut up and kiss me

Edited by: Lady Deirdre at: 9/18/01 8:39:41 am
babzee 
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 8:48:07 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Quote:
Please keep in mind while reading this: it was written by a Jew, not a muslim.


Are you inferring that a Jew would naturally lie re Islam??????

Strength and Honor

The enemy is fanaticism, extremism, intolerance, hate.

Lady Deirdre
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 8:57:38 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
I was afraid of this, but couldn't put it any other way.

What I meant was, that if you ask a Christian to describe Islam, you get A, you ask a Jew to describe Islam, you get B and if you ask a Muslim to describe Islam, you get C (not counting the A1, A2,A3,A4 etc you will undoubtedly get). Everyone sees different things and focussed on different things.

I was trying to avoid things like "I read about a muslim not having a western view on human rights, so they have no respect for life". Just trying to get people to think a little bit further instead of jumping to conclusions. Just like the writer, who obviously made an effort to be well-informed and balanced.

Communiaction: shut up and kiss me

babzee 
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 9:03:20 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Quote:
Just trying to get people to think a little bit further instead of jumping to conclusions.


So you just jumped to the conclusion that none of us was capable or willing to think?

Thanks.

Strength and Honor

The enemy is fanaticism, extremism, intolerance, hate.

Lady Deirdre
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 9:05:22 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Quote:
So you just jumped to the conclusion that none of us was capable or willing to think?

Thanks.
Oops! Okay, get your point now. Excuse me while I go wash off my bit of arrogance...

But... is it okay if I don't poof-edit that remark? I hate it when others do that and am reluctant to for this reason.

Communiaction: shut up and kiss me

sarony 
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 10:27:13 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Ok, I wasn't going to even get into this, but I have a dear friend who is Muslim. As I work with this wonderful godly man every day, we've had many opportunities over the years to talk about our two different religions, Islam and Christianity, and even more so during the past week. The following quote from the afore metioned article screamed out to me, for it is very true of many Muslims of today, esp. my friend:

Quote:
For many Muslims, the doctrines of holy war and of Dar al Islam are irrelevant to their faith, and have in effect been allowed to lapse. Sufis, or Muslim mystics, go further, transforming holy war into a spiritual doctrine, a battle against one's own imperfections.


Now I'm no expert on Islam, but I have been amazed at how similar the teachings of Islam are to Christianity as my friend has discussed these issues with me. They are very similar indeed.

He refuses to even consider bin Laden a Muslim. He sees little or no teachings of true Islam in him. My friend's family still lives in Damascus (all but his immediate, who are all now American citizens), and he was high ranking military there at one time before coming to America (without the government's permission, I might add) and becoming an American citizen many years ago. This is a very learned man, with several PhDs, and insists one of the main problems with Muslim extremists is lack of education. For example, only 1/3 of Afghans can read at all. The rest rely on their extremist militant (and in his opinion ignorant) religious leaders for all information pertaining to Islam and the rest of the world, as they often don't have access to TV, radio, etc. They have no way of reading the Arabic Koran text, to find out for themselves what the truth of Islam is. Sadly, some of these religious leaders have twisted the faith of Islam so radically that it doesn't resemble true Islam at all. These people are often the blind leading the blind, willing to die for the lies they have grown up believing and have been indoctrinated in. Quite honestly, it's often all they have to hold on to, to give them purpose in their life. They hide behind the idea of fighting for God, but in actually lack the true knowledge of Allah to ever be able to please Him as they so desperately want to do. Add in the general culture of not enough food and necessities for living, crazy regimes taking over and terrorizing and torturing their own people, lack of education, being cut off from the rest of the world in about every way, putting the blame for their lot on Western civilization, and madmen masquerading as leaders, sometimes religious leaders of those countries, and it's no wonder we're in this mess. The woes of these cultures are so incredibly complex, there is no easy answer.

I'm rambling here, and I apologize. I have a million thoughts running through my head, and they seem to propogate as I read this thread. I will pass one thing my Muslim friend told me, much to my shock, the day after this happened. He was very distraught over the events of the 11th, so much so he left work for the rest of the day to be with his family and go to mosque. He told me unfortunately these kind of terrorists, esp. those from a part of the world he is all too familiar with, don't usually respond to diplomatic/economic processes. It's not a language they are fluent in. They understand one thing, and if you want to get their attention, you have to speak to them in their language sometimes. He almost started crying when he spoke these words. I truly hope he is not right on this point. May God help us all. Suffice it to say, this is going to get messy I fear, regardless of the road the U.S. takes in this journey.

My ramblings are over. Thanks for having patience with me.

The world is heading for mutiny / When all we want is unity / We may rise and fall, but in the end / We meet our fate together / One / The only way is one - "One", lyrics by Creed

babzee 
Perch Pro
(9/18/01 10:37:17 am)
Re: An Afghani-American Perspective
Sarony -- thanks so much for your 'ramblings'
Especially this
Quote:
They hide behind the idea of fighting for God, but in actually lack the true knowledge of Allah to ever be able to please Him as they so desperately want to do. Add in the general culture of not enough food and necessities for living, crazy regimes taking over and terrorizing and torturing their own people, lack of education, being cut off from the rest of the world in about every way, putting the blame for their lot on Western civilization, and madmen masquerading as leaders, sometimes religious leaders of those countries, and it's no wonder we're in this mess. The woes of these cultures are so incredibly complex, there is no easy answer.
Edited to try to curb my resentment of people jumping to conclusions about our inability to think.

Strength and Honor

The enemy is fanaticism, extremism, intolerance, hate.

Edited by: babzee  at: 9/18/01 10:40:39 am
Page 1 2 3 4 5


- The Crowe' s Perch - Russell's Revellers: get your fan fuel here:) - Russell Crowe, an unofficial site -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 6.3.5
Copyright ©1999-2001 ezboard, Inc.